It's an itch which needs to be scratched: net/rrdtool came from net/mrtg, which was a good location for it. net/mrtg has later been moved to net-mgmt/mrtg. net/rrdtool is "Round Robin Database Tools", therefor it's better if it moves to databases/rrdtool. Same with net/rrdtool10. Fix: Repocopy: net/rrdtool -> databases/rrdtool net/rrdtool10 -> databases/rrdtool10 Change CATEGORIES: net -> databases graphics Affected ports: databases/mysqlard devel/p5-RRDTool-OO devel/p5-SVN-Statistics graphics/orca mail/couriergraph mail/mailgraph net/cacti net/happystats net/jffnms net/jrobin net/p5-POE-Component-RRDTool net/p5-RRD-Simple net/php4-rrdtool net/php5-rrdtool net/py-rrdpipe net/py-rrdtool_lgpl net/rrdtool net/rrdtool10 net/smokeping net-mgmt/bigsister net-mgmt/cricket net-mgmt/flowscan net-mgmt/ifgraph net-mgmt/junipoll net-mgmt/nagiosgraph net-mgmt/nagiostat net-mgmt/nav net-mgmt/nfsen net-mgmt/nrg net-mgmt/ourmon net-mgmt/torrus security/amavis-stats sysutils/dtc sysutils/dtc-toaster sysutils/munin-main sysutils/symon www/drraw I volunteer to do the changes in the above mentioned ports.
Responsible Changed From-To: freebsd-ports-bugs->demon Over to maintainer
State Changed From-To: open->repocopy over to portmgr for requested repocopy.
Responsible Changed From-To: demon->portmgr over to portmgr for requested repocopy.
State Changed From-To: repocopy->feedback I dunno why you ignored my private e-mail about this PR so i repeat it there. I think rrdtool should stay in the same category as mrtg, so proper category for it is net-mgmt. rrdtool is close to net-mgmt rather than database. So i have nothing agains repo-copy to net-mgmt, but i think databases category is bad choice.
Responsible Changed From-To: portmgr->demon I dunno why you ignored my private e-mail about this PR so i repeat it there. I think rrdtool should stay in the same category as mrtg, so proper category for it is net-mgmt. rrdtool is close to net-mgmt rather than database. So i have nothing agains repo-copy to net-mgmt, but i think databases category is bad choice.
State Changed From-To: feedback->open > I dunno why you ignored my private e-mail about this PR so i repeat it > there. Please send me the message-id of the email and I'll see if I have received it. As far as I can see, I didn't receive it. > I think rrdtool should stay in the same category as mrtg, so proper > category for it is net-mgmt. > rrdtool is close to net-mgmt rather than database. As where MRTG was intended for all aspects of network device monitoring (polling of devices, storage of data, graphing of data), RRDTool is "nothing more" than a database layer and grapher of data. If you look at the programs supplied with it, it doesn't even have anything which can be used for gathering the information from remote devices. The only tool, related to RRDTool, which I know which has to live in net-mgmt is cacti, because that one is actually providing a network management feature. They even say of their product: "Cacti is a complete network graphing solution designed to harness the power of RRDTool's data storage and graphing functionality.". Nothing which states that RRDTool is anything but data storage and graphing. NetBSD has located it under databases instead of under net. Fedora Core has located it under databases instead of under net. Suse has located it under Science / Math instead of under Network. Ubuntu has located it under Utilities instead of under network. That's why I submitted this PR.
Hello Dmitry, We're close to getting a maintainer timeout on this PR again, and I would like you not to get angry again because of this. I didn't get your first email, I didn't get a reply to my reply to you. Nothing is noted in GNATS. On saturday morning, if a maintainer timeout occurs, I'll be setting this one again to repocopy and assign it to portmgr for it. Just a heads up. Edwin -- Edwin Groothuis edwin@freebsd.org http://www.mavetju.org
On Wed, Jun 20, 2007 at 02:50:07AM +0000, Edwin Groothuis wrote: > Hello Dmitry, > > We're close to getting a maintainer timeout on this PR again, and > I would like you not to get angry again because of this. > > I didn't get your first email, I didn't get a reply to my reply to > you. Nothing is noted in GNATS. > > On saturday morning, if a maintainer timeout occurs, I'll be setting > this one again to repocopy and assign it to portmgr for it. > > Just a heads up. > > Edwin > Yes, you are right. Sorry for the delay. I was busy at work. I still feel uncomfortable with databases category, despite NetBSD and Fedora Core went this way. And i still think that most users of rrdtool assosiate is with network management, and would first search for it in net-mgmt category. If you have strong desire to move it to databases, please do. Also change MAINTAINER to either ports@ or someone else. Thanks for your work.
State Changed From-To: open->repocopy Over to portmgr for repocopy.
Responsible Changed From-To: demon->portmgr Over to portmgr for repocopy. Despite your request, I'm not going to reassign maintainership. That is outside the scope of this PR, and probably unnecessary.
State Changed From-To: repocopy->open Repocopy complete.
Responsible Changed From-To: portmgr->edwin Repocopy complete.
edwin 2007-07-05 06:19:49 UTC FreeBSD ports repository Modified files: . MOVED databases Makefile databases/mysqlard Makefile databases/rrdtool Makefile devel/p5-RRDTool-OO Makefile graphics/orca Makefile mail/couriergraph Makefile mail/mailgraph Makefile net Makefile net/p5-POE-Component-RRDTool Makefile net/p5-RRD-Simple Makefile net/php4-rrdtool Makefile net/php5-rrdtool Makefile net/py-rrdpipe Makefile net/py-rrdtool_lgpl Makefile net/rrdman Makefile net/rubygem-rrdtool Makefile net/smokeping Makefile net-mgmt/bigsister Makefile net-mgmt/cacti Makefile net-mgmt/cricket Makefile net-mgmt/flowscan Makefile net-mgmt/ifgraph Makefile net-mgmt/junipoll Makefile net-mgmt/nagiosgraph Makefile net-mgmt/nagiostat Makefile net-mgmt/nfdump-devel Makefile net-mgmt/nfsen Makefile net-mgmt/nfsen-devel Makefile net-mgmt/nrg Makefile net-mgmt/ourmon Makefile net-mgmt/torrus Makefile security/amavis-stats Makefile sysutils/dtc Makefile sysutils/ganglia-monitor-core Makefile sysutils/munin-main Makefile sysutils/symon Makefile www/drraw Makefile Removed files: net/rrdtool Makefile distinfo pkg-descr pkg-plist net/rrdtool/files patch-bindings-Makefile.in patch-doc-Makefile.in patch-examples-Makefile.in Log: First steps in a big migration: Move net/rrdtool to databases/rrdtool. It's an itch which needs to be scratched: net/rrdtool came from net/mrtg, which was a good location for it. net/mrtg has later been moved to net-mgmt/mrtg. net/rrdtool is "Round Robin Database Tools", therefor it's better if it moves to databases/rrdtool. Same with net/rrdtool10. PR: ports/112942 Submitted by: Edwin Groothuis <edwin@mavetju.org> Revision Changes Path 1.1410 +2 -1 ports/MOVED 1.618 +1 -0 ports/databases/Makefile 1.2 +1 -1 ports/databases/mysqlard/Makefile 1.68 +1 -1 ports/databases/rrdtool/Makefile 1.7 +1 -1 ports/devel/p5-RRDTool-OO/Makefile 1.4 +1 -1 ports/graphics/orca/Makefile 1.4 +1 -1 ports/mail/couriergraph/Makefile 1.32 +1 -1 ports/mail/mailgraph/Makefile 1.10 +1 -1 ports/net-mgmt/bigsister/Makefile 1.36 +1 -1 ports/net-mgmt/cacti/Makefile 1.29 +1 -1 ports/net-mgmt/cricket/Makefile 1.26 +1 -1 ports/net-mgmt/flowscan/Makefile 1.7 +1 -1 ports/net-mgmt/ifgraph/Makefile 1.9 +1 -1 ports/net-mgmt/junipoll/Makefile 1.5 +1 -1 ports/net-mgmt/nagiosgraph/Makefile 1.6 +1 -1 ports/net-mgmt/nagiostat/Makefile 1.13 +1 -1 ports/net-mgmt/nfdump-devel/Makefile 1.8 +1 -1 ports/net-mgmt/nfsen-devel/Makefile 1.8 +1 -1 ports/net-mgmt/nfsen/Makefile 1.6 +1 -1 ports/net-mgmt/nrg/Makefile 1.4 +1 -1 ports/net-mgmt/ourmon/Makefile 1.3 +1 -1 ports/net-mgmt/torrus/Makefile 1.1887 +0 -1 ports/net/Makefile 1.7 +1 -1 ports/net/p5-POE-Component-RRDTool/Makefile 1.7 +1 -1 ports/net/p5-RRD-Simple/Makefile 1.3 +1 -1 ports/net/php4-rrdtool/Makefile 1.2 +1 -1 ports/net/php5-rrdtool/Makefile 1.8 +1 -1 ports/net/py-rrdpipe/Makefile 1.7 +1 -1 ports/net/py-rrdtool_lgpl/Makefile 1.2 +1 -1 ports/net/rrdman/Makefile 1.68 +0 -82 ports/net/rrdtool/Makefile (dead) 1.32 +0 -3 ports/net/rrdtool/distinfo (dead) 1.7 +0 -26 ports/net/rrdtool/files/patch-bindings-Makefile.in (dead) 1.5 +0 -14 ports/net/rrdtool/files/patch-doc-Makefile.in (dead) 1.6 +0 -11 ports/net/rrdtool/files/patch-examples-Makefile.in (dead) 1.4 +0 -10 ports/net/rrdtool/pkg-descr (dead) 1.22 +0 -119 ports/net/rrdtool/pkg-plist (dead) 1.3 +1 -1 ports/net/rubygem-rrdtool/Makefile 1.40 +1 -1 ports/net/smokeping/Makefile 1.4 +1 -1 ports/security/amavis-stats/Makefile 1.17 +1 -1 ports/sysutils/dtc/Makefile 1.21 +1 -1 ports/sysutils/ganglia-monitor-core/Makefile 1.13 +1 -1 ports/sysutils/munin-main/Makefile 1.13 +1 -1 ports/sysutils/symon/Makefile 1.4 +1 -1 ports/www/drraw/Makefile _______________________________________________ cvs-all@freebsd.org mailing list http://lists.freebsd.org/mailman/listinfo/cvs-all To unsubscribe, send any mail to "cvs-all-unsubscribe@freebsd.org"
State Changed From-To: open->closed Committed, thanks!