Bug 12586

Summary: "Sane" or insane? Get your act together.
Product: Ports & Packages Reporter: huver <huver>
Component: Individual Port(s)Assignee: freebsd-ports (Nobody) <ports>
Status: Closed FIXED    
Severity: Affects Only Me    
Priority: Normal    
Version: Latest   
Hardware: Any   
OS: Any   

Description huver 1999-07-10 06:00:02 UTC
sane: was broken since 3.1, broken in 3.2, still broken in -current!

  1. It was not built with a working GIMP on the build system, hence there
  is no "GIMP plugin" compiled in.  The "you can symlink xsanimage to
  GIMP plugin directory" note is crap.

  2, It was built with the wrong glib, xscanimage absolutely finds no
  SCSI scanner, whereas "camcontrol" clearly shows they are there.  The
  ports/Makefile has it right: it needs gtk/glib-1.2.2, why was the
  package built with -1.2.3?

xsane is the same way.

Fix: 

If you cannot test the packages you build, don't bother putting them
out on release.  Require whoever builds a package must sign off "tested"
before sending these "useless" packages out the door, and put that
person's name in the +COMMENTS!  This most basic QC concept that workers
around the world know quite well, you guys sure aren't showing any.

I had to spend 2 days pulling in glib/gtk etc. plus GIMP sources to
build them, so sane can be build properly: all because I had to
back glib/gtk down.

Before 2.2.8, I never had this sort of problem; since 2.2.8, I've had
to learn to read Spanish html docs, install packages that turn out
useless, and rebuild ibraries.

This irresponsible behavior must stop.
How-To-Repeat: Pull the package off CD or from packages ftp, install and see.
"sane" my foot, INSANE is more like it.
Comment 1 jkh freebsd_committer freebsd_triage 1999-07-10 06:24:06 UTC
State Changed
From-To: open->closed

1. Sane works just fine on my system, with and without gimp, used directly 
from the ports collection.  You have to configure sane first, however, 
and that seems unfortunately to be beyond the submitter's ability. 

2. The submitter's mother wears combat boots and I'm closing this PR.