Bug 192388
| Summary: | Mk/bsd.php5.mk: Regression: mod_php5 is out of the dependency tree when WANT_PHP_WEB is set | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Product: | Ports & Packages | Reporter: | Melvyn Sopacua <m.r.sopacua> |
| Component: | Ports Framework | Assignee: | Alex Dupre <ale> |
| Status: | Closed Works As Intended | ||
| Severity: | Affects Many People | ||
| Priority: | --- | ||
| Version: | Latest | ||
| Hardware: | Any | ||
| OS: | Any | ||
Not sure who to assign this to, let's try ale@ first. If you are using the port system the dependency will be added, since it will look at the installed SAPIs. Packages are different, you should expect inconsistencies if you change default OPTIONS. Anyway, what the port system does is more than it should, I could completely remove such tricky check and let all ports depends on core php and stop. (In reply to Alex Dupre from comment #2) > If you are using the port system the dependency will be added, since it will > look at the installed SAPIs. I installed it in a clean system using the ports. The results posted are what the package has recorded, but they were still being installed. I changed the options simply to trigger a mod_php5 build, since WANT_PHP_WEB is supposed to pull in a web-capable SAPI or bail out with a fatal error. Neither happened. So this means it's not working as intended. > Anyway, what the port system > does is more than it should, I could completely remove such tricky check and > let all ports depends on core php and stop. I actually think that's best. With mod_php5 out of the main php5 port, it becomes impossible to maintain a WANT_PHP_WEB semantic that works reliably. Instead, depending ports should be fixed to offer support for the SAPIs they want to support. At present I maintain at least one port that wants both a CLI and a web sapi, and I'm more then happy to change the options and add PHP SAPI selection and help to fix others as well. |
1. databases/phpmyadmin has WANT_PHP_WEB set 2. On a clean environment I want to install that port and expect apache and mod_php5 built for me. 3. Because I don't want fpm or cgi, I unset the options for the lang/php5 options dialog. Expected result: phpMyAdmin depends on apache and mod_php5 among others. Result: # pkg query -F /var/packages/test/All/phpMyAdmin-4.2.7.txz %do lang/php5 archivers/php5-bz2 textproc/php5-ctype security/php5-filter devel/php5-json converters/php5-mbstring security/php5-mcrypt databases/php5-mysqli security/php5-openssl www/php5-session archivers/php5-zlib # pkg query -F /var/packages/test/All/php5-5.4.30.txz %do textproc/libxml2 devel/pcre # pkg info -lF /var/packages/test/All/php5-5.4.30.txz|grep bin/ /usr/local/bin/php /usr/local/bin/php-config /usr/local/bin/phpize So, there is no php-cgi or fpm, but www/mod_php5 is not in phpMyAdmin's dependencies, which means WANT_PHP_WEB is not satisfied, yet no errors are generated.