Bug 279168
| Summary: | sysutils/bsdisks: add qt6 support. | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Product: | Ports & Packages | Reporter: | Eric Camachat <eric> | ||||||
| Component: | Individual Port(s) | Assignee: | Gleb Popov <arrowd> | ||||||
| Status: | Closed FIXED | ||||||||
| Severity: | Affects Only Me | CC: | bugzilla.freebsd, d8zNeCFG, dsh, tcberner | ||||||
| Priority: | --- | Flags: | arrowd:
maintainer-feedback+
|
||||||
| Version: | Latest | ||||||||
| Hardware: | Any | ||||||||
| OS: | Any | ||||||||
| Attachments: |
|
||||||||
Thanks for the patch. I don't think flavorizing is necessary, can you please change your patch so that bsdisks would become qt6-only? Created attachment 250854 [details]
qt6 only
Remove flavors, change to Qt6 only.
A commit in branch main references this bug: URL: https://cgit.FreeBSD.org/ports/commit/?id=91ee9ec8e0dbfa97b298e6498900938e71762837 commit 91ee9ec8e0dbfa97b298e6498900938e71762837 Author: Eric Camachat <eric@camachat.org> AuthorDate: 2024-05-21 18:38:37 +0000 Commit: Gleb Popov <arrowd@FreeBSD.org> CommitDate: 2024-05-21 19:06:00 +0000 sysutils/bsdisks: Switch to Qt 6 PR: 279168 sysutils/bsdisks/Makefile | 8 +++++--- 1 file changed, 5 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) (In reply to Gleb Popov from comment #1) Could you please explain why bsdisks should be qt6 only? - With the current state of ports this means that just for bsdisks, qt6 is being pulled in. I would prefer to stay with qt5 as long as the default version of KDE is not switched to qt6. -- Martin Qt 6 is already being pulled for many things. Switch applications to Qt 6 is a first step before the full switch. For now we'll have to live with two version installed at the same time, unfortunately. Thank you for the quick answer. Currently, the set of ports I am using does not need any qt6 component (KDE, firefox, thunderbird, qgis, libreoffice, vlc, ...). So bsdisks flavorized for both qt5 and qt6 would cut down on the number of required ports at least for me, and probably also for quite a few more people. Please reconsider. -- Martin (In reply to Martin Birgmeier from comment #6) Moin moin I hope to push the KDE Applications to 24.xx update in this quarter (still testing) -- this will move almost all KDE applications to use Qt6. So the move to bsdisks to Qt6 is one of the important steps to make that big update possible. mfg Tobias (In reply to Martin Birgmeier from comment #6) I second Martins objection, sysutils/bsdisks is the only (out of ~500) ports resp. package that pollutes my xfce4-session based DE with QT6 - despite using plethora of QT5/KDE applications. For now I'm reverting locally, but please reconsider this change. Here's a compilation of KDE/QT related desktop applications, which are up to date (major version wise) and do a great job without needing QT6 for double-purpose overhead, ONLY sysutils/bsdisks would (currently does) depend on QT6: elisa-23.08.5 Audio player with QML and KDE Plasma integration gpgme-qt-headers-1.23.2 Shared headers for the Gpgme Qt bindings gpgme-qt5-1.23.2 Gpgme Qt5 bindings gwenview-23.08.5_3 Image viewer and browser for KDE kColorPicker-qt5-0.3.1 Qt-based color picker library with popup menu kImageAnnotator-qt5-0.7.1 Library for image-annotation tools kaccounts-integration-23.08.5_5 System to administer web accounts for the KDE desktop kate-23.08.5_2 Basic editor framework for the KDE system kcolorchooser-23.08.5 KDE application to select colors from the screen or from a palette kf5-attica-5.115.0 Open Collaboration Services API library KDE5 version kf5-breeze-icons-5.115.0 Breeze icon theme for KDE kf5-kdeclarative-5.115.0_1 KF5 library providing integration of QML and KDE Frameworks kf5-kdelibs4support-5.115.0_1 KF5 porting aid from KDELibs4 kf5-kinit-5.115.0_1 KF5 process launcher to speed up launching KDE applications kf5-qqc2-desktop-style-5.115.0 Qt QuickControl2 style for KDE kf5-syndication-5.115.0,1 KDE RSS feed handling library kile-3.0.b3_45 LaTeX source editor for KDE kirigami-addons-0.11.0 Component library for KDE Kirigami kqtquickcharts-23.08.5 QtQuick plugin to render interactive charts krusader-2.8.1 Twin panel file manager for KDE, like midnight or norton commander ktouch-23.08.5_1 Touch typing tutor for KDE libaccounts-qt5-1.16_5 Qt5 wrapper for SSO framework libdbusmenu-qt5-0.9.3.160420160218_13 Qt5 implementation of the DBusMenu protocol libfm-qt-1.4.0 Qt port of libfm libkdcraw-qt5-23.08.5_1 LibRaw interface for KDE libkdegames-23.08.5 Libraries used by KDE games libkexiv2-23.08.5 Exiv2 library interface for KDE liblxqt-1.4.0 Shared library for LXQt applications libqtxdg-3.12.0 Qt implementation of freedesktop.org xdg specs lximage-qt-1.4.0 Image viewer lxqt-menu-data-1.4.1 Freedesktop.org compliant menu files for lxqt marble-23.08.5_1 Virtual globe and world atlas for KDE neochat-23.08.5_4 Glossy Matrix IM client based on KDE technologies okteta-0.26.15,1 KDE hex editor okular-23.08.5_4 KDE universal document viewer pdfmixtool-qt5-1.1.1_3 Application to split, merge, rotate and mix PDF files phonon-qt5-4.12.0_2 KDE multimedia framework pinentry-qt5-1.3.0 Qt 5 version of the GnuPG password dialog polkit-qt-1-qt5-0.200.0 Qt wrapper around Polkit libraries poppler-qt5-24.02.0_1 Qt 5 bindings to poppler py39-qt5-pyqt-5.15.10_1 Python bindings for the Qt5 toolkit, QtCore module py39-qt5-sip-12.13.0 Python to C and C++ bindings generator qca-qt5-2.3.8_1 Cross-platform crypto API for Qt 5 qcoro-qt5-0.10.0 Coroutines for Qt qscintilla2-qt5-2.14.1 Qt 5 port of the Scintilla C++ editor class qt5-assistant-5.15.13p4 Qt 5 documentation browser (KDE patched) qt5-buildtools-5.15.14p140 Qt build tools (KDE patched) qt5-concurrent-5.15.13p142 Qt multi-threading module (KDE patched) qt5-connectivity-5.15.13p4 Qt connectivity (Bluetooth/NFC) module (KDE patched) qt5-core-5.15.14p140 Qt core non-graphical module (KDE patched) qt5-dbus-5.15.14p140 Qt D-Bus inter-process communication module (KDE patched) qt5-declarative-5.15.14p28 Qt declarative framework for dynamic user interfaces (KDE patched) qt5-designer-5.15.13p4 Qt 5 graphical user interface designer (KDE patched) qt5-graphicaleffects-5.15.13p0 Qt Quick graphical effects (KDE patched) qt5-gui-5.15.14p140 Qt graphical user interface module (KDE patched) qt5-help-5.15.13p4 Qt online help integration module (KDE patched) qt5-imageformats-5.15.14p7 Qt plugins for additional image formats (KDE patched) qt5-linguisttools-5.15.13p4 Qt localization tools (KDE patched) qt5-location-5.15.13p6 Qt location module (KDE patched) qt5-multimedia-5.15.13p2 Qt audio, video, radio and camera support module (KDE patched) qt5-network-5.15.14p140 Qt network module (KDE patched) qt5-opengl-5.15.13p142 Qt 5-compatible OpenGL support module (KDE patched) qt5-printsupport-5.15.13p142 Qt print support module (KDE patched) qt5-qmake-5.15.14p140 Qt Makefile generator (KDE patched) qt5-quick3d-5.15.13p1 Set of controls for building complete interfaces in Qt Quick3D (KDE patched) qt5-quickcontrols-5.15.13p0 Set of controls for building complete interfaces in Qt Quick (KDE patched) qt5-quickcontrols2-5.15.13p5 Set of controls for building complete interfaces in Qt Quick (KDE patched) qt5-remoteobjects-5.15.13p0 Qt5 Remote Objects module (KDE patched) qt5-script-5.15.16p0_2 Qt 4-compatible scripting module qt5-scripttools-5.15.16p0_1 Qt Script additional components qt5-sensors-5.15.13p0 Qt sensors module (KDE patched) qt5-serialport-5.15.13p0 Qt functions to access serial ports (KDE patched) qt5-speech-5.15.13p1 Accessibilty features for Qt5 (KDE patched) qt5-sql-5.15.14p140 Qt SQL database integration module (KDE patched) qt5-sqldrivers-sqlite3-5.15.13p142 Qt SQLite 3 database plugin (KDE patched) qt5-svg-5.15.14p5 Qt SVG support module (KDE patched) qt5-testlib-5.15.13p142 Qt unit testing module (KDE patched) qt5-uiplugin-5.15.13p4 Custom Qt widget plugin interface for Qt Designer (KDE patched) qt5-uitools-5.15.13p4 Qt Designer UI forms support module (KDE patched) qt5-wayland-5.15.14p57 Qt5 wrapper for Wayland (KDE patched) qt5-webchannel-5.15.13p3 Qt 5 library for integration of C++/QML with HTML/js clients (KDE patched) qt5-webengine-5.15.16.p9_2 Qt 5 library to render web content qt5-websockets-5.15.13p2 Qt implementation of WebSocket protocol (KDE patched) qt5-widgets-5.15.14p140 Qt C++ widgets module (KDE patched) qt5-x11extras-5.15.13p0 Qt platform-specific features for X11-based systems (KDE patched) qt5-xml-5.15.13p142 Qt SAX and DOM implementations (KDE patched) qt5-xmlpatterns-5.15.13p0 Qt support for XPath, XQuery, XSLT and XML Schema (KDE patched) qtkeychain-qt5-0.14.3 Platform independent Qt API for storing passwords quazip-qt5-1.4_1 Qt/C++ wrapper for ZIP/UNZIP package signon-qt5-8.61 D-Bus service performing user authentication (In reply to Tobias C. Berner from comment #7) Thanks Tobias, highly appreciated! But until your major change hasn't settled resulting in QT5 to be the exceptional dependency in the ports tree, sysutils/bsdisks depending unconditionally on QT6 is the wrong decision imho. |
Created attachment 250818 [details] sysutils/bsdisks: add qt6 support. Add Qt6 flavor in sysutils/bsdisks, meanwhile also make devel/kf6-solid depends on sysutils/bsdisks@qt6.