Bug 73918

Summary: [NEW PORT] multimedia/mencvd: MPlayer Sources (DVD) to (S)VCD ripping and burning
Product: Ports & Packages Reporter: Manuel Rábade - MiG <mig>
Component: Individual Port(s)Assignee: Michael Johnson <ahze>
Status: Closed FIXED    
Severity: Affects Only Me    
Priority: Normal    
Version: Latest   
Hardware: Any   
OS: Any   
Attachments:
Description Flags
mencvd-0.3.shar none

Description Manuel Rábade - MiG 2004-11-14 00:01:02 UTC 
Shell script around mplayer, mjpegtools, vcdimager, and cdrdao to create
(S)VCD's from anything that mplayer can reproduce.

- Manuel Rabade Garcia
mig@mig-29.net

Generated with FreeBSD Port Tools 0.63
Comment 1 Michael Johnson freebsd_committer freebsd_triage 2004-11-14 05:38:24 UTC 
Responsible Changed
From-To: freebsd-ports-bugs->ahze

Grab
Comment 2 Michael Johnson 2004-11-14 05:45:49 UTC 
Is this port is really necessary?

This port depends on mplayer and mplayer  installs the
same mencvcd script in share/mplayer/tools.

Maybe you could submit patches to Thomas E. Zander (maintainer of 
mplayer)
to install this script in bin/ and use bash so it will actually work.

Michael
Comment 3 Michael Johnson freebsd_committer freebsd_triage 2004-11-14 05:46:08 UTC 
State Changed
From-To: open->feedback

Asked submitter for feedback
Comment 4 Manuel Rábade - MiG 2004-11-14 19:51:58 UTC 
Michael Johnson, who happens to be smarter than you, thinks:
> Is this port is really necessary?
> 


I think is necesarry to handle its dependencies, which are very diferent
of the mplayer dependencies.

> This port depends on mplayer and mplayer  installs the
> same mencvcd script in share/mplayer/tools.
> 
> Maybe you could submit patches to Thomas E. Zander (maintainer of 
> mplayer)
> to install this script in bin/ and use bash so it will actually work.


Maybe is better, the only problem are the dependencies of mencvd.

Also i found that the script can be downloaded from its own page,
allowing us to remove the hardcoded distfile.

Well, as i said, the motivation of this port is to handle its
dependencies. 

¿What do you think? ¿What is the best for the ports? :)

Sorry for my bad english.

Thanks a lot :)

-- 
Manuel Rabade Garcia
 WWW - http://mig-29.net
 GPG - 1024D/AA3325C0 2002-09-30
 Fingerprint - D2E5 76E1 CE2D 8783 545D  1F41 399B 5765 AA33 25C0
Comment 5 Michael Johnson 2004-11-14 20:18:40 UTC 
On Nov 14, 2004, at 2:51 PM, Manuel Rabade Garcia wrote:

> Michael Johnson, who happens to be smarter than you, thinks:
>> Is this port is really necessary?
>>
>
> I think is necesarry to handle its dependencies, which are very 
> diferent
> of the mplayer dependencies.


Most of these are already included in mplayer, and what's not there 
could easily be added
(upon Thomas's approval of course)

But I still think fixing what's in multimedia/mplayer is more important 
than adding a
new port that fixes the issue.

If you still feel this port needs to be added to ports please convert 
patch-aa
in to a REINPLACE_CMD line in the Makefile that also respects 
${LOCALBASE}

Michael
>> This port depends on mplayer and mplayer  installs the
>> same mencvcd script in share/mplayer/tools.
>>
>> Maybe you could submit patches to Thomas E. Zander (maintainer of
>> mplayer)
>> to install this script in bin/ and use bash so it will actually work.
>
> Maybe is better, the only problem are the dependencies of mencvd.
>
> Also i found that the script can be downloaded from its own page,
> allowing us to remove the hardcoded distfile.


> Well, as i said, the motivation of this port is to handle its
> dependencies.
>
> ¿What do you think? ¿What is the best for the ports? :)
>
> Sorry for my bad english.
>
> Thanks a lot :)
>
> -- 
> Manuel Rabade Garcia
>  WWW - http://mig-29.net
>  GPG - 1024D/AA3325C0 2002-09-30
>  Fingerprint - D2E5 76E1 CE2D 8783 545D  1F41 399B 5765 AA33 25C0
Comment 6 Manuel Rábade - MiG 2004-11-25 02:54:06 UTC 
Michael Johnson, who happens to be smarter than you, thinks:
> 
> On Nov 14, 2004, at 2:51 PM, Manuel Rabade Garcia wrote:
> 
> >Michael Johnson, who happens to be smarter than you, thinks:
> >>Is this port is really necessary?
> >>
> >
> >I think is necesarry to handle its dependencies, which are very 
> >diferent
> >of the mplayer dependencies.
> 
> Most of these are already included in mplayer, and what's not there 
> could easily be added
> (upon Thomas's approval of course)
> 


Well, i think that dependencies like cdrdao, vcdimager and mjpegtools
are not included in mplayer.

> But I still think fixing what's in multimedia/mplayer is more important 
> than adding a
> new port that fixes the issue.
> 


I agree.

> If you still feel this port needs to be added to ports please convert 
> patch-aa
> in to a REINPLACE_CMD line in the Makefile that also respects 
> ${LOCALBASE}
> 


Ok.

I will send an email to Thomas E. Zander to ask him what he thinks about
mencvcd.

Could you close the pr? If it goes into a separated port i will fix some
issues like the REIMPLACE_CMD and send a new pr.

Thanks and sorry for the delayed response :)

-- 
Manuel Rabade Garcia
 WWW - http://mig-29.net
 GPG - 1024D/AA3325C0 2002-09-30
 Fingerprint - D2E5 76E1 CE2D 8783 545D  1F41 399B 5765 AA33 25C0
Comment 7 Michael Johnson freebsd_committer freebsd_triage 2004-11-25 03:00:57 UTC 
State Changed
From-To: feedback->closed

Closed at submitters request