Created attachment 163084 [details] example_id3_tags XMMS don't show tags with ID3v2.3! Tags with ID3v2.4 show correct. Examples: $ id3 W.A.S.P._-_04_Miss\ You.mp3 File: W.A.S.P._-_04_Miss You.mp3 Metadata: ID3v2.3 Title: Miss You Artist: W.A.S.P. Album: Golgotha Track: 4 Year: 2015 Genre: Metal $ id3 tagtest.ID3v2.4.mp3 File: tagtest.ID3v2.4.mp3 Metadata: ID3v2.4 Title: Test Name Artist: Test Artist Album: Test Album Track: 7/16 Genre: Classical Comment: Test Comments In attachment screenshot ID3 information from XMMS. root@vladiom:~ # pkg info | grep xmms xmms-1.2.11_27 X Multimedia System -- audio player with Winamp GUI root@vladiom:~ # uname -srm FreeBSD 10.2-RELEASE-p7 amd64
This is simply not true. XMMS displays ID3v2.3 tags just fine. What you observe must be a problem with a specific file.
It is true! In the playlist tags show correct, but in the window for edit tags not display! XMMS some files normal show tags, some files no. For example (see attachment) screenshot ID3 information from QMMP and XMMS. Download this files from: ftp://ftp.vladiom.net/pub/Tempo/
Created attachment 163327 [details] example_id3_tags_2 example_id3_tags_2
Comment for files (ftp://ftp.vladiom.net/pub/Tempo/): 07 My Hero.mp3 - downloaded from Internet 9. W.A.S.P. - Golgotha_tag_ok.mp3 - downloaded from Internet W.A.S.P._-_09_Golgotha.mp3 - created RipperX tagtest.ID3v2.4_tag_ok.mp3 - downloaded from Internet
Created attachment 163372 [details] xmms_playlist
P.S. Maybe in the window for edit tags XMMS use only ID3v1?
Thank you, with your example files I can reproduce the issue, even on a different operating system. This appears to be an upstream bug. I don't know when or if I'll find the time to debug XMMS's ID3 code.
Created attachment 163667 [details] XMMS_id3v1_tags
I checked - XMMS written data in the ID3v1! See attachment (XMMS_id3v1_tags) and ftp (file W.A.S.P._-_04_Miss You.mp3).
So what? :) When?
After 10 months (from the date of registration PR), bug still not fix. Example files (with tags) still present: ftp://ftp.vladiom.net/pub/Tempo/mp3_id_tag/
I will not fix this and I resign my maintainership.
To be fair xmms is so old last release is in 2009, I would suggest you try a port named Audacious which uses the same base as xmms. this should show ID3 tags. Thank you and have a great day.
This issue should likely have been closed (rejected) by naddy as per comment 12, as they were maintainer at the time, or further isolation requested from the reporter which could then have been resolved with 'feedback timeout'. If there is a specific and reasonable course of action that can be taken, please re-open the issue. An example of a specific courses of action is there is a newer release or a commit/patch that that has been identified that once applied to the port can be confirmed to resolve the issue.